本文利用GM(1,1)模型预测2024—2030年全国职工医保基金和居民医保基金收支状况,在考虑辅助生殖技术纳入医保报销范围的现实背景下,构建精算模型测算其分别对职工医保基金和居民医保基金运行状况的影响。研究发现:第一,测算期内职工医保基金总体运行状况良好,至2030年累计结存为120245.28亿元,但居民医保基金2030年开始出现穿底风险,赤字额为803.26亿元;第二,即使职工参保群体的渗透率较高,但辅助生殖技术纳入医保报销范围对居民参保群体需求释放更为明显,即参加居民医保的育龄夫妇接受辅助生殖治疗的增量更高。第三,当辅助生殖技术渗透率不变时,测算期内因辅助生殖技术带来的新生儿总量为299.52万人。提高渗透率会使新生儿数量显著增加,渗透率低、中、高增长方案下测算期内新生儿总量分别增加63.24万人、110.17万人、157.10万人,可见辅助生殖技术纳入医保报销范围有利于缓解我国生育率下降的局面。第四,同渗透率增长方案下,居民医保基金在辅助生殖技术的支出高于职工医保基金,且辅助生殖技术给居民医保基金带来的支出压力远高于职工医保基金。渗透率高增长方案下,2030年因辅助生殖技术带来的职工医保基金支出仅占基金支出的0.24%,但居民医保基金该占比达0.72%,约是职工医保基金支出压力的3倍。第五,若不对居民医保制度进行政策干预以维持基金精算平衡,辅助生殖技术纳入医保报销范围给居民医保基金带来的支出最终会转嫁为财政负担。以渗透率高增长方案为例,2030年财政弥补居民医保基金赤字的负担从803.26亿元上升至1502.68亿元。针对以上结论,本文从如何减少不孕不育患者、提高辅助生殖技术的渗透率和成功率、促进居民医保基金可持续以及防范辅助生殖技术纳入医保报销范围可能产生的道德风险等角度提出相关建议,以更好地为完善辅助生殖技术纳入医保报销的相关措施提供参考,有助于平衡社会效益与医保基金的可持续发展。
Abstract
In this paper, the GM (1,1) model was used to predict the income and expenditure of national employees’ medical insurance fund and residents’ medical insurance fund from 2024 to 2030. Under the realistic background of considering the inclusion of assisted reproductive technology in the reimbursement of medical insurance, an actuarial model was constructed to measure its impact on the operation of employees’ medical insurance fund and residents’ medical insurance fund, respectively. The study found that, first, during the calculation period, the employees' medical insurance fund was in good overall performance, with a cumulative balance of 12024.528 billion yuan by 2030. However, the residents' medical insurance fund began to face the risk of imbalance in 2030, with a deficit of 80.326 billion yuan. Second, even though the penetration rate of the employees’ medical insurance group is high, the inclusion of assisted reproductive technology in the medical insurance reimbursement will release the demand of the residents’ medical insurance group more obviously, that is, the increment of assisted reproductive treatment for the couples of childbearing age who participate in the residents’ medical insurance is higher. Third, when the penetration rate of assisted reproductive technology remained unchanged, the total number of newborns caused by assisted reproductive technology during the calculation period would be 2.9952 million. Increasing the penetration rate will significantly increase the number of newborns. Under the low, medium and high penetration rate growth plan, the total number of newborns will increase by 0.6324 million, 1.1017 million and 1.5710 million during the calculation period, respectively. It is clear that the inclusion of assisted reproductive technology in medical insurance reimbursement is conducive to alleviating the situation of fertility rate decline in China. Fourth, under the same penetration rate growth plan, the expenditure of the residents’ medical insurance fund on assisted reproductive technology is higher than that of the employees’ medical insurance fund, and the expenditure pressure brought by assisted reproductive technology to the residents’ medical insurance fund is much higher than that of the employees’ medical insurance fund. For example, under the plan of high penetration rate growth, the expenditure of employees’ medical insurance fund due to assisted reproductive technology would only account for 0.24% of the fund expenditure in 2030, but the proportion of residents’ medical insurance fund would reach 0.72%, which was about three times the expenditure pressure of employees’ medical insurance fund. Fifth, if there is no policy intervention in the residents’ medical insurance system to maintain the actuarial balance of the fund, the expenditure brought by the inclusion of assisted reproductive technology in the reimbursement of medical insurance will eventually be transferred to the financial burden of the residents’ medical insurance fund. Taking the high penetration rate growth plan as an example, the financial burden of making up the deficit of the residents’ medical insurance fund will rise from 80.326 billion yuan to 150.268 billion yuan in 2030. In view of the above conclusions, this paper puts forward relevant suggestions from the perspectives of how to reduce the number of infertile patients, improve the penetration rate and success rate of assisted reproductive technology, promote the sustainability of residents' medical insurance fund, and prevent the possible moral risks caused by the inclusion of assisted reproductive technology in medical insurance reimbursement, so as to provide references for improving the relevant measures of the inclusion of assisted reproductive technology in medical insurance reimbursement, which is helpful to balance the social benefits and the sustainable development of medical insurance fund.
关键词
医疗保险 /
医保基金 /
辅助生殖技术 /
精算分析
Key words
medical insurance /
medical insurance fund /
assisted reproductive technology /
actuarial analysis
{{custom_sec.title}}
{{custom_sec.title}}
{{custom_sec.content}}
参考文献
[1] 王超群. 中国普惠性生育保障制度设计及其筹资需求[J].社会保障评论,2024,8(02):135-147.
[2] 张翠玲,姜玉,庄亚儿,等.中国女性终身不育水平估计——基于第七次全国人口普查数据的分析[J].人口研究,2023,47(03):78-93.
[3] 任远. 生育水平的影响机制和低生育率社会的生育服务支持[J].复旦学报(社会科学版),2023,65(06):162-170.
[4] 全紫薇,刘晓曦.健康中国背景下我国辅助生殖技术的发展与进步[J].医学研究杂志,2022,51(10):6-8.
[5] 国家卫健委.中国妇幼健康事业发展报告(2019)(二)[J].中国妇幼卫生杂志,2019,10(06):1-7.
[6] 田莉峰,夏雷震,吴兴武,等.江西省人类辅助生殖技术质量控制中心:2020年辅助生殖技术数据报告[J].江西医药,2023,58(07):877-883.
[7] HUANG R, YU J Y, HE W C, et al.Feasibility analysis of China's medical insurance coverage of assisted reproductive technology[J]. Scientific reports, 2024, 14(1): 7998.
[8] 吴彬,罗仁夏,曹建平.等维新息灰色系统GM(1,1)模型在福建省医保统筹基金风险预测中的应用[J].中国卫生统计,2015,32(04):613-615.
[9] 吴岚怡,王前.基于GM(1,1)模型我国基本医疗保险基金结余预测分析[J].中国卫生经济,2021,40(09):33-38.
[10] 许燕,杨再贵.基于GM(1,1)模型的城乡居民基本养老保险参保率测算[J].保险研究,2019(04):116-127.
[11] 张帆,孙涛,樊立华.GM(1,1)模型在社会医疗保险统筹基金预测中的应用[J].中国卫生资源,2009,12(06):269-270+283.
[12] 李亚青.社会医疗保险财政补贴增长及可持续性研究——以医保制度整合为背景[J].公共管理学报,2015,12(01):70-83+156.
[13] 张宁,朱淑惠,王杰琼,等.中医药与辅助生殖技术[M].广州:世界图书广东出版公司,2013:310.
[14] BOTCHAN A, HAUSER R, GAMZU R, et al.Results of 6139 artificial insemination cycles with donor spermatozoa[J]. Human reproduction, 2001, 16(11): 2298-2304.
[15] 曾益,李姝,张冉,等.门诊共济改革、渐进式延迟退休年龄与职工医保基金可持续性——基于多种方案的模拟分析[J].保险研究,2021(04):91-105.
[16] 杨华磊,曹顺子,郝杰.职工医保统筹基金的财政压力研究——基于门诊共济改革政策的分析[J].中国医疗保险,2023(11):41-48.
[17] JIE Q, YUANYUAN W, XIAOHONG L, et al.A Lancet commission on 70 years of women's reproductive, maternal, newborn, child, and adolescent health in China[J]. Lancet, 2021,397(10293): 2497-2536.
[18] SAUER V M.Reproduction at an advanced maternal age and maternal health[J].Fertility and Sterility,2015,103(5):1136-1143.
[19] LERIDON H.Can assisted reproduction technology compensate for the natural decline in fertility with age? a model assessment[J]. Human reproduction, 2004, 19(7): 1548-1553.
[20] SAITO H, JWA S C, KUWAHARA A, et al.Assisted reproductive technology in Japan: a summary report for 2015 by The Ethics Committee of The Japan Society of Obstetrics and Gynecology[J]. Reproductive medicine and biology, 2018, 17(1): 20-28.
基金
国家社会科学基金一般项目“医保DRG付费的基金监管效果评价及政策优化研究”(24BGL277); 中央高校基本科研业务费项目“医疗保险市级统筹对城镇职工个体医疗费用的影响研究”(2722022BY017)